Wednesday, March 26, 2014

ActiveMQ - Network of Brokers Explained - Part 4

In the previous part 3 , we have seen how ActiveMQ helps distinguish remote consumers from local consumers which helps in determining shorter routes from message producers to consumers.

In this part 4,  we will look into how to load balance concurrent consumers on remote brokers.

Let’s consider a bit more advanced configuration to load balance concurrent message consumers on a queue in remote brokers as shown below. 

Part 4 - Network of brokers 

In the above configuration, we have a message producer sending messages into a queue moo.bar on broker-1. Broker-1 establishes network connectors to broker-2 and broker-3. Consumer C1 consumes messages from queue moo.bar on broker-2 while consumers C2 and C3 are concurrent consumers on queue moo.bar on broker-3. 

Let's see this in action


Let's create three brokers instances...
  1. Ashwinis-MacBook-Pro:bin akuntamukkala$ pwd
    /Users/akuntamukkala/apache-activemq-5.8.0/bin

  2. Ashwinis-MacBook-Pro:bin akuntamukkala$./activemq-admin create ../cluster/broker-1

  3. Ashwinis-MacBook-Pro:bin akuntamukkala$./activemq-admin create ../cluster/broker-2

  4. Ashwinis-MacBook-Pro:bin akuntamukkala$./activemq-admin create ../cluster/broker-3

  5. Fix the broker-2 and broker-3 transport, amqp connectors and jetty http port by modifying the corresponding conf/activemq.xml and conf/jetty.xml as follows:

    BrokerOpenwire PortJetty HTTP PortAMQP Port
    broker-1
    61616
    8161
    5672
    broker-2
    61626
    9161
    5682
    broker-3
    61636
    10161
    5692


  6. Fix network connector on broker-1 such that messages on queues can be forwarded dynamically to consumers on broker-2 and broker-3. This can be done by adding the following XML snippet into broker-1's conf/activemq.xml

    <networkConnectors>

        
    <networkConnector
    1.   name="Q:broker1->broker2"
        uri="static:(tcp://localhost:61626)"
        duplex="false"
        decreaseNetworkConsumerPriority="true"
        networkTTL="2"
        dynamicOnly="true">
        <excludedDestinations>
           <topic physicalName="&gt;" />
        </excludedDestinations>
      </networkConnector>

      <networkConnector
         name="Q:broker1->broker3"
         uri="static:(tcp://localhost:61636)"
         duplex="false"
         decreaseNetworkConsumerPriority="true"
         networkTTL="2"
         dynamicOnly="true">
         <excludedDestinations>
              <topic physicalName="&gt;" />
         </excludedDestinations>
      </networkConnector>
    </networkConnectors>

  7.  Start broker-2, broker-3 and broker-1. We can start these in any order.
    1. /apache-activemq-5.8.0/cluster/broker-3/bin$ ./broker-3 console
    2. /apache-activemq-5.8.0/cluster/broker-2/bin$ ./broker-2 console
    3. /apache-activemq-5.8.0/cluster/broker-1/bin$ ./broker-1 console
  8. Let's start the consumers C1 on broker-2 and C2, C3 on broker-3 but on the same queue called "moo.bar"
    1. /apache-activemq-5.8.0/example$ ant consumer -Durl=tcp://localhost:61626 -Dsubject=moo.bar
    2. /apache-activemq-5.8.0/example$ ant consumer -Durl=tcp://localhost:61636 -Dsubject=moo.bar -DparallelThreads=2

      The consumer subscriptions are forwarded by broker-2 and broker-3 to their neighboring broker-1 which has a network connector established to both broker-2 and broker-3 by the use of advisory messages. 
  9. Let's review the broker web consoles to see the queues and corresponding consumers. 
    1. We find that broker-2's web console shows one queue "moo.bar" having 1 consumer, broker-3's web console shows one queue "moo.bar" having 2 concurrent consumers
    2. Though there are three consumers (C1 on broker-2 and C2,C3 on broker-3), broker-1 sees only two consumers (representing broker-2 and broker-3).
    3. http://localhost:8161/admin/queues.jsp










    4. This is because the network connector from broker-1 to broker-2 and to broker-3 by default has a property "conduitSubscriptions" which is true. 
      Due to which broker-3's C2 and C3 which consume messages from the same queue "moo.bar" are treated as one consumer in broker-1.
  10. Let's produce 30 messages into broker-1's queue moo.bar and see how the messages are divvied among the consumers C1, C2 and C3
Shows how the messages were propagated from producer to consumers C1, C2, C3
As seen above, even though there were three consumers and 30 messages, they didn't get to process 10 messages each as C2, C3 subscriptions were consolidated into one consumer at broker-1. 

conduitSubscriptions="true" is a useful setting if we were creating subscribers on topics as that would prevent duplicate messages. More on this in part 5.

So, in order to make C2 and C3 subscriptions on queue moo.bar propagate to broker-1, let's redo the same steps 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10 after setting conduitSubscriptions="false" in broker-1's network connector configuration in conf/activemq.xml 

Here is the new network connector configuration snippet for broker-1:

<networkConnectors>
  <networkConnector
    name="Q:broker1->broker2"
    uri="static:(tcp://localhost:61626)"
    duplex="false"
    decreaseNetworkConsumerPriority="true"
    networkTTL="2"
    conduitSubscriptions="false"
    dynamicOnly="true">
    <excludedDestinations>
       <topic physicalName="&gt;" />
    </excludedDestinations>
  </networkConnector>
  <networkConnector
    name="Q:broker1->broker3"
    uri="static:(tcp://localhost:61636)"
    duplex="false"
    decreaseNetworkConsumerPriority="true"
    networkTTL="2"
    conduitSubscriptions="false"
    dynamicOnly="true">
    <excludedDestinations>
       <topic physicalName="&gt;" />
    </excludedDestinations>
  </networkConnector>
</networkConnectors>

Upon restarting the brokers and consumers C1, C2 and C3 and producing 30 messages into broker-1's moo.bar queue, we find that all of the three consumer subscriptions are visible at broker-1. As a result broker-1 dispatches 10 messages to each of the consumers in a round-robin fashion to load balance. This is depicted pictorially below. 

Shows how the messages were propagated from producer to consumers C1, C2, C3
Broker-1's web console @ http://localhost:8161/admin/queueConsumers.jsp?JMSDestination=moo.bar shows that broker-1 now sees 3 consumers and dispatches 10 messages to each consumer



Thus in this part 4 of the blog series, we have seen how we can load balance remote concurrent consumers which are consuming messages from a queue. 

As always, your comments and feedback is appreciated!

In the next part 5, we will explore how the same scenario will play out if we were to use a topic instead of a queue. Stay tuned...

References

Resources

  • The configuration files (activemq.xml and jetty.xml) of all the brokers used in this blog are available here.

3 comments:

  1. Hi Ashwini. Great Tutorial! thank you a lot for the effort. Pls, I really cant wait for part 6 (How to prevent stuck messages). I have tried several different config parameters but always get messages that are not consumed. Maybe can you give us some pointers here ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Edison for your appreciation. I am working on part 5 and 6 now. I should have them published in a few days and will send out a tweet @akuntamukkala

      Delete
    2. Edison, regarding the stuck messages, you may have to look into disabling audit (so duplicate messages are not rejected) and turn on replayWhenNoConsumers flag in conditionalNetworkBridgeFilterFactory. I have used these settings in the past. Your exact use case may be very different. I am writing up a blog about this.

      Delete